[NTLUG:Discuss] ntlug.org back from the dead again

Pat Regan thehead at patshead.com
Wed Jul 6 16:41:31 CDT 2005


Chris Cox wrote:
> Pat Regan wrote:
>> Is there a technical reason why they don't make a switch that can auto
>> negotiate properly?
> 
> Auto negotiation is only DEFINED when both sides are auto negotiating.
> It's not a Cisco problem.
> 
> The times where I've seen Cisco not work auto-auto is with older Sun
> boxes.  You can peruse the wayback machine for details.  Both claimed
> that each other had misinterpreted the spec..... I didn't care, I felt
> that it was in their best interests to just make it work.. instead of
> pointing the finger at each other.  Not sure who moved on it... but I
> haven't had the problem in about 4-5 years now.

I seem to recall hearing about our desktop support guys being told to by
the network guys to not set the PCs to auto negotiate because it "caused
problems."  I assumed they were having the same issues we had with some
of our servers.

This has been a few years and I have slept since then, so my memory
could be quite fuzzy :).

Pat


More information about the Discuss mailing list